Can cultural competence-based techniques help reduce existing racial and ethnic health
disparities?
This research has found the theoretical connections between cultural competence and
health disparities frequently presented by scholars and policy-makers to be potentially
unsound. An extensive literature review and policy analysis conducted indicates that the
relationship between cultural competence-based techniques and documented racial and
ethnic health disparities is predicated on select studies suggesting ‘patient satisfaction’
results from cultural competence-based programs and thus plays a crucial role in reducing
health disparities (Betancourt et al., 2003; Baquet, 2005; Anderson, 2011; James et al,.
2011; Lie et. Al., 2011). These studies provide no evidentiary support for the increase of
patient satisfaction alongside cultural competency-based efforts, or the reduction of
health disparities alongside experienced patient satisfaction.
My MA research has also elicited a number of critical issues pertaining to concepts of
‘cultural competence,’ such as implicit power dynamics, paradoxes of ‘knowing’,
problematic interpretations of ‘culture,’ and the reification of racial hierarchies. These
concerns suggest that ‘achieving’ or even ‘working towards’ cultural competency-based
frameworks may, in fact, be prejudicial.
Collectively, this MA research prompts the question(s): Given the tenuous relationship
between cultural competence and documented health disparities, and the potentially
problematic nature of cultural competency frameworks, should cultural competencybased framework be utilized in medical education. There may be other advantages to
utilizing cultural competence-based frameworks within medical education curricula, and
these will be explored.
Principal Research Question:
My doctoral research will seek to address the following principal research question:
“Are cultural competency-based frameworks, which presently inform medical education
curricula, ethically defensible?”
The innovation of this research lies in the fact that such critical investigations of cultural
competency and articulated implications for present medical education still remain in
their infancy.
Research Design:
The initial exploration of cultural competence conducted within my MA research will
largely substantiate two chapters concerning the present conception and purpose of
cultural competency-based efforts.
A number of specific questions will guide my research. In combination, the prior
literature and its voids, together with my MA dissertation observations suggest the
following issues will prove relevant in my investigation:
What is articulated as the reason/justification for New Zealand’s current cultural
competence-based medical education program(s)?
What is aim of cultural competence within the context of medical education?
What is the observed or implicit relationship between concepts of race, ethnicity and
culture?
– How are these concepts constructed/implicated?
Methodology:
My research design will involve the use of philosophical investigation, which includes
reviewing the scholarly literature on cultural competence and medical education, and
critically analyzing arguments in support, and in question, of cultural competency-based
efforts. I will be extensively reviewing the current cultural competence-based programmes
within both of New Zealand’s medical schools and speaking with key informants on the
topic.
To critically address the concept of cultural competence, this thesis will introduce some of
the methodological tools from the scholarship of Michel Foucault. This approach provides
novel way of interpreting and problematizing knowledge systems, providing relevant but
new questions, objects of enquiry and epistemological and ontological flexible dimensions of
research analysis.
While the above speaks to the nature of this PhD most broadly, the research will be
approached as an exploration that unveils and shapes itself as it progresses.
Reading List/ Bibliography:
Adams, V., & Kaufman, S. R. (2011). Ethnography and the Making of Modern Health
Professionals. Culture, medicine and psychiatry, 35(2), 313–320.
Anderson, J., Perry, J., Blue, C., Browne, A., Henderson, A., Khan, K. B., … Smye, V.
(2003). “ Rewriting” Cultural Safety Within the Postcolonial and Postnational Feminist
Project: Toward New Epistemologies of Healing. Advances in Nursing Science, 26(3),
196–214.
Antman, K., Abraido-Lanza, A. F., Blum, D., Brownfield, E., Cicatelli, B., Debor, M. D., …
Gradishar, W. (2002). Reducing Disparities in Breast Cancer Survival: A Columbia
University and Avon Breast Cancer Research and Care Network Symposium*. Breast
cancer research and treatment, 75(3), 269–280.
Baquet, C. R., Bezuneh, M., & Mishra, S. I. (2005). Addressing health disparities through
community-academic partnerships: the Maryland model. Different Paths for Different
People: Reducing Health Disparities. Retrieved from
letin.pdf#page=4
Betancourt, J. R., & Green, A. R. (2010a). Commentary: linking cultural competence training
to improved health outcomes: perspectives from the field. Academic Medicine, 85(4),
583.
Betancourt, J. R., & Green, A. R. (2010b). Commentary: linking cultural competence training
to improved health outcomes: perspectives from the field. Academic Medicine, 85(4),
583.
Betancourt, J. R., Green, A. R., Carrillo, J. E., & Ananeh-Firempong, O. (2003a). Defining
cultural competence: a practical framework for addressing racial/ethnic disparities in
health and health care. Public health reports, 118(4), 293.
Betancourt, J. R., Green, A. R., Carrillo, J. E., & Ananeh-Firempong, O. (2003b). Defining
cultural competence: a practical framework for addressing racial/ethnic disparities in
health and health care. Public Health Reports, 118(4), 293–302.
Borau, K., Ullrich, C., Feng, J., & Shen, R. (2009). Microblogging for language learning:
Using twitter to train communicative and cultural competence. In Advances in Web Based
Learning–ICWL 2009 (pp. 78–87). Springer. Retrieved from
http://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-642-03426-8_10
Brach, C., & Fraserirector, I. (2000a). Can cultural competency reduce racial and ethnic health
disparities? A review and conceptual model. Medical Care Research and Review, 57(4
suppl), 181–217.
Brach, C., & Fraserirector, I. (2000b). Can cultural competency reduce racial and ethnic health
disparities? A review and conceptual model. Medical Care Research and Review, 57(4
suppl), 181–217.
Braveman, P. (2006). Health disparities and health equity: concepts and measurement. Annu.
Rev. Public Health, 27, 167–194.
Braveman, P., & Gruskin, S. (2003). Defining equity in health. Journal of epidemiology and
community health, 57(4), 254–258.
Carberry, C. (1998). Contesting competency: cultural safety in advanced nursing practice.
Collegian: Journal of the Royal College of Nursing Australia, 5(4), 9–13.
Carter-Pokras, O., & Baquet, C. (2002). What is a“ health disparity”? Public health reports,
117(5), 426.
Casas, J. M. (2013). Review of Multicultural care: A clinician’s guide to cultural competence.
Cultural diversity & ethnic minority psychology, 19(2), 229–230. doi:10.1037/a0029610
Casas-Zamora, J. A., & Ibrahim, S. A. (2004a). Confronting Health Inequity: The Global
Dimension. American Journal of Public Health, 94(12), 2055–2058.
Casas-Zamora, J. A., & Ibrahim, S. A. (2004b). Confronting Health Inequity: The Global
Dimension. American Journal of Public Health, 94(12), 2055–2058.
Chambers, D., Wharrad, H., Todhunter, F., Chambers, K., Nencini, D., & McGarry, J. (2011).
PROMOTING CULTURAL AWARENESS IN HEALTH CARE STUDENTS WITH
THE USE OF VIRTUAL MOBILITY, COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGIES AND
AUTHENTIC CASE STUDIES. ICERI2011 Proceedings, 5589–5594.
Commission, J. (2010a). Advancing effective communication, cultural competence, and
patient-and family-centered care: A roadmap for hospitals. Joint Commission.
Commission, J. (2010b). Advancing effective communication, cultural competence, and
patient-and family-centered care: A roadmap for hospitals. Joint Commission.
Cooney, C. (1994). A comparative analysis of transcultural nursing and cultural safety.
Nursing praxis in New Zealand inc, 9(1), 6.
Cross, T. L. (2008). Cultural competence. Encyclopedia of social work, 20, 487–491.
Désirée A. Lie MD, M., Elizabeth Lee-Rey MD, M. P. H., Md, A. G., Ms, S. B., & Clarence
H. Braddock III MD, M. P. H. (2011). Does Cultural Competency Training of Health
Professionals Improve Patient Outcomes? A Systematic Review and Proposed Algorithm
for Future Research. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 26(3), 317–325.
doi:10.1007/s11606-010-1529-0
Emmison, M. (2003). Social Class and Cultural Mobility Reconfiguring the Cultural
Omnivore Thesis. Journal of sociology, 39(3), 211–230.
Farr, C., & Virchow, K. (2009). Towards a common definition of global health. Lancet, 373,
1993–95.
Foucault, M. (1982). The subject and power. Critical inquiry, 8(4), 777–795.
Gonzalez-Lee, T., & Simon, H. J. (1987). Teaching Spanish and cross-cultural sensitivity to
medical students. Western Journal of Medicine, 146(4), 502–504.
Goode, T., Jones, W., & Mason, J. (2012). A guide to planning and implementing cultural
competence organization self assessment. Published 2002.
Hernandez, M., Nesman, T., Mowery, D., Acevedo-Polakovich, I., & Callejas, L. (2009).
Cultural competence: a literature review and conceptual model for mental health services.
Psychiatric Services, 60(8), 1046–1050.
Horowitz, S. (2005). Cultural Competency Training in US Medical Education: Treating
Patients from Different Cultures. Alternative & Complementary Therapies, 11(6), 290–
294.
Horton, S. (2006). The double burden on safety net providers: Placing health disparities in the
context of the privatization of health care in the US. Social Science & Medicine, 63(10),
2702–2714.
Ikemoto, L. C. (2003). Racial disparities in health care and cultural competency. . Louis ULJ,
48, 75.
Imel, Z. E., Baldwin, S., Atkins, D. C., Owen, J., Baardseth, T., & Wampold, B. E. (2011).
Racial/ethnic disparities in therapist effectiveness: a conceptualization and initial study of
cultural competence. Journal of counseling psychology, 58(3), 290.
Jacob, J., Gray, B., & Johnson, A. (2013). The asian american family and mental health:
implications for child health professionals. Journal of pediatric health care: official
publication of National Association of Pediatric Nurse Associates & Practitioners, 27(3),
180–188. doi:10.1016/j.pedhc.2011.08.006
James, L., Smith, C., & Laird, L. (2011a). Cultural Competence in Action: An Analysis of
Cultural Competency Outcome Assessment in the Behavioral Health Field. Retrieved
from
James, L., Smith, C., & Laird, L. (2011b). Cultural Competence in Action: An Analysis of
Cultural Competency Outcome Assessment in the Behavioral Health Field. Retrieved
from
Jeffreys, M. (2010a). Teaching cultural competence in nursing and health care. Springer
Publishing Company. Retrieved from
http://books.google.co.nz/books?hl=en&lr=&id=Pu07C7jjqn4C&oi=fnd&pg=PP2&dq=
%22health+disparities%22+%22cultural+competence%22&ots=xsE7qni1UT&sig=Y0hi
_dsveXUYavRozB34Ma5hwCU
Jeffreys, M. (2010b). Teaching cultural competence in nursing and health care. Springer
Publishing Company. Retrieved from
http://books.google.co.nz/books?hl=en&lr=&id=Pu07C7jjqn4C&oi=fnd&pg=PP2&dq=c
ultural+competence&ots=xsE7qng9NX&sig=Ynr8TAtls-kHkJ27AL3JqCr9Etw
Jeffreys, M. R. (2005). Clinical nurse specialists as cultural brokers, change agents, and
partners in meeting the needs of culturally diverse populations. Journal of Multicultural
Nursing and Health, 11(2), 41.
Kapoor, R., Dike, C., Burns, C., Carvalho, V., & Griffith, E. E. H. (2013). Cultural
competence in correctional mental health. International journal of law and psychiatry.
doi:10.1016/j.ijlp.2013.04.016
Karmali, K., Grobovsky, L., Levy, J., & Keatings, M. (2011a). Enhancing cultural competence
for improved access to quality care. Healthcare quarterly (Toronto, Ont.), 14, 52.
Karmali, K., Grobovsky, L., Levy, J., & Keatings, M. (2011b). Enhancing cultural competence
for improved access to quality care. Healthcare quarterly (Toronto, Ont.), 14, 52.
Keppel, K. G. (2007). Ten largest racial and ethnic health disparities in the United States
based on Healthy People 2010 objectives. American Journal of Epidemiology, 166(1),
97–103.
Kilbourne, A. M., Switzer, G., Hyman, K., Crowley-Matoka, M., & Fine, M. J. (2006).
Advancing health disparities research within the health care system: a conceptual
framework. Journal Information, 96(12). Retrieved from
http://ajph.aphapublications.org/doi/pdf/10.2105/AJPH.2005.077628
Kirmayer, L. J. (2012a). Cultural competence and evidence-based practice in mental health:
epistemic communities and the politics of pluralism. Social Science & Medicine.
Retrieved from
Kirmayer, L. J. (2012b). Cultural competence and evidence-based practice in mental health:
epistemic communities and the politics of pluralism. Social Science & Medicine.
Retrieved from
Krieger, N., Chen, J. T., Waterman, P. D., Rehkopf, D. H., & Subramanian, S. V. (2005).
Painting a truer picture of US socioeconomic and racial/ethnic health inequalities: the
Public Health Disparities Geocoding Project. Journal Information, 95(2). Retrieved from
Kumagai, A. K., & Lypson, M. L. (2009a). Beyond cultural competence: critical
consciousness, social justice, and multicultural education. Academic Medicine, 84(6),
782–787.
Kumagai, A. K., & Lypson, M. L. (2009b). Beyond cultural competence: critical
consciousness, social justice, and multicultural education. Academic Medicine, 84(6),
782–787.
Lasser, K. E., Himmelstein, D. U., & Woolhandler, S. (2006). Access to care, health status,
and health disparities in the United States and Canada: results of a cross-national
population-based survey. Journal Information, 96(7). Retrieved from
Lavizzo-Mourey, R. J., & MacKenzie, E. (1996). Cultural competence–an essential hybrid for
delivering high quality care in the 1990’s and beyond. Transactions of the American
Clinical and Climatological Association, 107, 226–237.
Lee, S. S.-J., Mountain, J., & Koenig, B. A. (2001). Meanings of Race in the New Genomics:
Implications for Health Disparities Research, The. Yale J. Health Pol’y L. & Ethics, 1,
33.
Lie, D. A., Elizabeth Lee-Rey MD, M. P. H., Gomez, A., Bereknyei, S., & Braddock III, C. H.
(2011). Does cultural competency training of health professionals improve patient
outcomes? A systematic review and proposed algorithm for future research. Journal of
general internal medicine, 26(3), 317–325.
Lie, D., Carter-Pokras, O., Braun, B., & Coleman, C. (2012). What do health literacy and
cultural competence have in common? Calling for a collaborative health professional
pedagogy. Journal of Health Communication, 17(sup3), 13–22.
Lloyd, L. L. J., Ammary, N. J., Epstein, L. G., Johnson, R., & Rhee, K. (2006). A
transdisciplinary approach to improve health literacy and reduce disparities. Health
Promotion Practice, 7(3), 331.
Lu, M. C., & Halfon, N. (2003). Racial and ethnic disparities in birth outcomes: a life-course
perspective. Maternal and child health journal, 7(1), 13–30.
Lynch, E. W., & Hanson, M. J. (2004). Developing cross-cultural competence: A guide for
working with children and their families. ERIC. Retrieved from
http://www.eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/recordDetail?accno=ED491776
Moore, M. L., Moos, M. K., & Callister, L. C. (2010). Health disparities and cultural
competence in the 21st century. White Plains, NY: March of Dimes Foundation.[Context
Link].
Nelson, A. (2002). Unequal treatment: confronting racial and ethnic disparities in health care.
Journal of the National Medical Association, 94(8), 666.
Nylund, D. (2006). Critical multiculturalism, whiteness, and social work: Towards a more
radical view of cultural competence. Journal of Progessive Human Services, 17(2), 27–
42.
Pacquiao, D. F. (2008). Nursing care of vulnerable populations using a framework of cultural
competence, social justice and human rights. Contemporary nurse, 28(1-2), 189–197.
Papps, E., & Ramsden, I. (1996). Cultural safety in nursing: The New Zealand experience.
International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 8(5), 491–497.
Peek, M. E., Wilson, S. C., Bussey-Jones, J., Lypson, M., Cordasco, K., Jacobs, E. A., …
Brown, A. F. (2012). A study of national physician organizations’ efforts to reduce racial
and ethnic health disparities in the United States. Academic Medicine, 87(6), 694–700.
Polaschek, N. R. (1998). Cultural safety: A new concept in nursing people of different
ethnicities. Journal of Advanced Nursing-Institutional Subscription, 27(3), 452–457.
Ramsden, I. (1993). Cultural safety in nursing education in Aotearoa (New Zealand). Nursing
praxis in New Zealand inc, 8(3), 4.
Ramsden, I. (1997). Cultural safety: Implementing the concept. The social force of nursing
and midwifery. In: Te Whaiti P, McCarthy M, Durie A, eds. Mai i Rangiatea: Maori
wellbeing and development. Auckland, New Zealand: Auckland University Press and
Bridget Williams Books, 113–125.
Ramsden, I. (2002). Cultural safety and nursing education in Aotearoa and Te Waipounamu.
Victoria University of Wellington.
Reich, S. M., & Reich, J. A. (2006). Cultural competence in interdisciplinary collaborations: A
method for respecting diversity in research partnerships. American Journal of Community
Psychology, 38(1-2), 51–62.
Rowan, M. S., Rukholm, E., Bourque-Bearskin, L., Baker, C., Voyageur, E., & Robitaille, A.
(2013). Cultural competence and cultural safety in canadian schools of nursing: a mixed
methods study. International journal of nursing education scholarship, 10(1), 1–10.
doi:10.1515/ijnes-2012-0043
Saha, S., Beach, M. C., & Cooper, L. A. (2008). Patient Centeredness, Cultural Competence
and Healthcare Quality. Journal of the National Medical Association, 100(11), 1275–
1285.
Seeleman, C., Suurmond, J., & Stronks, K. (2009). Cultural competence: a conceptual
framework for teaching and learning. Medical education, 43(3), 229–237.
Sequist, T. D., Fitzmaurice, G. M., Marshall, R., Shaykevich, S., Marston, A., Safran, D. G., &
Ayanian, J. Z. (2010). Cultural Competency Training and Performance Reports to
Improve Diabetes Care for Black PatientsA Cluster Randomized, Controlled Trial.
Annals of Internal Medicine, 152(1), 40–46.
Smye, V., & Browne, A. J. (2002). “Cultural safety”and the analysis of health policy affecting
aboriginal people. Nurse researcher, 9(3), 42.
Somnath Saha MD, M. P. H., P Todd Korthuis MD, M. P. H., Cohn, J. A., Sharp, V. L.,
Moore, R. D., & Mary Catherine Beach MD, M. P. H. (2013). Primary care provider
cultural competence and racial disparities in HIV care and outcomes. Journal of general
internal medicine, 1–8.
Tavallali, A. G., Kabir, Z. N., & Jirwe, M. (2013). Ethnic Swedish Parents’ experiences of
minority ethnic nurses’ cultural competence in Swedish paediatric care. Scandinavian
journal of caring sciences. doi:10.1111/scs.12051
Taylor, B. A., Gambourg, M. B., Rivera, M., & Laureano, D. (2006). Constructing cultural
competence: Perspectives of family therapists working with Latino families. The
American Journal of Family Therapy, 34(5), 429–445.
Thom, D. H., & Tirado, M. D. (2006). Development and validation of a patient-reported
measure of physician cultural competency. Medical care research and review, 63(5),
636–655.
Thom, D. H., Tirado, M. D., Woon, T. L., & McBride, M. R. (2006). Development and
evaluation of a cultural competency training curriculum. BMC medical education, 6(1),
38.
Vaughn, L. M. (2009). Families and cultural competency: where are we? Family &
Community Health, 32(3), 247–256.
Washington, D. A. (2009). Critical race feminist bioethics: telling stories in law school and
medical school in pursuit of “cultural competency.” Albany Law Review, 72(4), 961+.
Wepa, D. (2005). Cultural Safety in Aotearoa New Zealand. Pearson Education New Zealand.
Whaley, A. L., & Davis, K. E. (2007). Cultural competence and evidence-based practice in
mental health services: A complementary perspective. American Psychologist, 62(6),
563.
Whitfield, K. E., Bogart, L. M., Revenson, T. A., & France, C. R. (2013). Introduction to the
Second Special Section on Health Disparities. Annals of Behavioral Medicine, 45(1), 1–
2.
Willen, S. S., & Carpenter-Song, E. (2013). Cultural Competence in Action: “Lifting the
Hood” on Four Case Studies in Medical Education. Culture, medicine and psychiatry.
doi:10.1007/s11013-013-9319-x
Williams, R. (1999). Cultural safety—what does it mean for our work practice? Australian
and New Zealand Journal of Public Health, 23(2), 213–214.
Zambrana, R. E., & Carter-Pokras, O. (2010). Role of acculturation research in advancing
science and practice in reducing health care disparities among Latinos. Journal
Information, 100(1). Retrieved from